I'm loving the show even more the second time. We just started the second season, which is thus far my favorite, and I am amazed at its complexity and attention to detail (well, most of the time). Of course, it also gives me a strong wave of nostalgia as well. The group of boys are the same age as I would have been at that time--maybe a year older. The music, those boys' interests (they are geeky outcasts), and the overall feel of the show touch something deep in my core ... to the point that I don't mind the horror aspect that much (I'm not a horror fan).
Watching it with Connor has also been interesting considering that he is now the age that the boys were in season one. With Connor currently at that age, and me remembering it vividly, we've had some interesting conversations ... which is another thing that I really like about watching this show.