I am extremely uncomfortable with that idea. Now, to be clear, I am not an expert in theology, and what I am about to express should not be interpreted as the teachings of the Catholic Church, to which I belong. Nor do I have even more than an iota of understanding about the way that God thinks, so if what I say leads you to blasphemous thoughts and eventually to the bowels of Hell, I deeply apologize (for whatever comfort that provides).
I believe that God is a just, merciful, and loving God. I believe that He will sacrifice (and has sacrificed) everything, including His body and blood, to assure that we can be saved from sin and death. I do not believe that He bases this on a punch-card for how often His people attend church. I do not believe that He bases this on "magical" incantations, secret phrases, or special ceremonies. I do believe that He bases it on how we treat both one another and the world that He has provided us.
To be clear, I do not believe that there is some sort of point system like the one in The Good Place which tallies our positive and negative actions and provides us with a score that sums up our life. Jesus makes it really clear in His teachings that there is nothing that we can do to clear the debt of sin that we have built. The only means of defeating death is through Him.
Now, I take this to mean that God, who created everything, is the only one with the power to save us. I do not take this (and please pardon the heresy) to mean that we have to acknowledge a particular form of His for Him to do this. I believe that it is entirely up to Him in the end, but His primary tenant for helping us through our lives is the instruction to love one another. In my view, condemning someone for going to the church (or synagogue, mosque, or temple) around the block is not a sign of love.
I choose to be a member of the Catholic Church because I believe living the tenants that it espouses leads to a happier life and a deeper connection to God ... for me. I believe that it offers a happier life and deeper connection to God for others who choose to follow its teachings as well. I do not believe that God will condemn someone for being raised in an Orthodox or Protestant faith (well, most of them anyway). That seems to run contrary to His nature. In fact, in most of Jesus' teachings, He uses the fundamentalists of His faith at the time (the Pharisees and Sadducees) as negative examples due to their tendency to rely of rituals for salvation rather than how they treat their neighbors. In fact, He goes out of His way to bring His salvation to those who weren't considered part of His religion.
And here's where I really get into trouble: I don't believe that God would deny a good soul to heaven and His presence just because they never heard His name before. I don't believe He would punish people who lived lives that benefited others just because they were born to a different faith (or no faith at all). I believe that a just, merciful, and loving God will do everything in His power to provide all people a pathway to Him.
A friend of mine once said that it would be nice if God was the way that I described. I believe He is. I do not believe that all faiths or beliefs are equal (mine is clearly the best). I do believe that God loves and cares for us in ways beyond our imaginings, and that His goodness ultimately wins over everyone in the end.